Delivery Drivers sue “It’s Only” Papa John’s Franchisee for unpaid wages

On June 16, 2017, Markovits, Stock & DeMarco, LLC filed a lawsuit on behalf of delivery drivers who work or worked for the “It’s Only” Papa John’s franchisees operating in the Cincinnati, Ohio area—It’s Only Downtown Pizza, Inc., It’s Only Pizza, Inc., It’s Only Downtown Pizza II Inc., and It’s Only Papa’s Pizza LLC. The plaintiff seeks to represent all delivery drivers who have worked for the “It’s Only” Papa John’s franchisee over the last three years. The plaintiff alleges that, together, the defendants operate approximately 27 restaurants in the Cincinnati area.

Click here to read the Class Action Complaint.

Under-reimbursed automobile expenses

In the Complaint, the plaintiff-delivery driver alleges that he and his similarly situated co-workers were all paid at or near minimum wage for the hours they worked inside the restaurant, and a “tipped wage” while making deliveries. In addition, the plaintiff alleges that he was denied proper reimbursement for gasoline, auto maintenance, and other expenses. Specifically, he alleges that Papa John’s delivery drivers are reimbursed at a flat rate per delivery that is insufficient to cover his out of pocket expenses. The unreimbursed expenses, therefore, amount to an unlawful “kickback” to the company, causing the plaintiff’s effective hourly rate to drop below minimum wage. The plaintiff seeks reimbursement of expenses at the IRS mileage reimbursement rate, and additional damages.

Unlawful deductions

In addition to requiring drivers to pay out-of-pocket for gas and auto expenses, the plaintiff alleges the “It’s Only” franchisees required their drivers to pay for uniforms and “insurance” (they did not receive health insurance) as a deduction from their paycheck. Like the under-reimbursed expenses, these deductions amount to “kickbacks” to the company, causing the plaintiff’s effective hourly rate to drop below minimum wage. The plaintiff seeks reimbursement of these deductions, and additional damages.

Unlawfully taking a “tip credit” from drivers’ wages

Finally, the plaintiff alleges that the defendants were not permitted to take a tip credit from his wages, therefore he is entitled to recovery of full minimum wage for all of the hours he worked. In order to take a tip credit, the law requires that the company provide “notice” of the laws surrounding the taking of a tip credit to their tipped employees. The plaintiff alleges that the company did not provide him or his fellow delivery drivers with proper notice of the tip credit. He seeks full minimum wage for all hours worked, plus additional damages.

Are you a delivery driver? MSD has extensive experience representing delivery drivers. Call us at 513-651-3700 or complete the form below to initiate a free and confidential case evaluation.


Delivery Drivers - Contact Us!

  • What company did you deliver for?

Please note that submitting this form does not create an attorney-client relationship, and you should not use it to submit confidential information.

ADVERTISING ONLY: The information on this blog is not, nor is not intended to be, legal advice. You should consult an attorney for individual advice regarding your own situation. 

Recent Posts

Leave a Comment